Columbus CrewNew York City FC
- 23Mohamed Farsi
- 9Juan Hernandez
- 25Sean Zawadzki
- 28Patrick Schulte
- 27Max Arfsten
- 31Steven Moreira
- 6Darlington Nagbe
- 4Rudy Camacho
- 10Diego Rossi
- 18Malte Amundsen
- 17Christian Ramirez
- 16Alonso Martinez
- 24Tayvon Gray
- 10Santiago Rodriguez
- 26Agustin Ojeda
- 13Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
- 17Hannes Wolf
- 55Keaton Parks
- 22Kevin O'Toole
- 5Birk Risa
- 6James Sands
- 49Matt Freese
